Policy Change Spurs Fear of School Raids Among Houston’s Immigrant Families

January 29, 2025

Recent policy changes under the Trump administration regarding immigration enforcement in sensitive locations have caused widespread concern among immigrant families in the Houston area. This new directive from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) allows Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents to conduct arrests in places such as schools, hospitals, and churches, which were previously off-limits under a protocol established in 2011. The potential implications of this shift for Houston’s educational institutions have left families with undocumented members fearing potential arrests at schools.

Before the new guidance, ICE agents were restricted from carrying out enforcement activities at sensitive locations unless there was an urgent reason, like a national security threat. This policy reversal permits ICE agents to arrest individuals who they believe to be in the country illegally if they have probable cause or a proper warrant. Probable cause can be based on someone revealing their undocumented status to law enforcement or carrying documents that prove their illegal status. Despite these changes, there have been no reported arrests at Houston schools to date. However, the uncertainty surrounding future enforcement actions, especially as the administration accelerates efforts to deport undocumented immigrants, continues to incite fear.

Immediate Reactions and Concerns

Community Anxiety and Fear

In the initial weeks following the implementation of the new policy, no known attempts by ICE to make arrests at local schools in Houston have been documented. Nevertheless, this has done little to reduce the anxiety among the immigrant community. Statements from administration officials, including Trump’s “border czar” Tom Homan, who has endorsed the idea of making arrests at schools if individuals are deemed to be national security or public safety threats, have only compounded these fears. Homan mentioned that gang members aged 14 to 17 attending schools could be considered threats.

The atmosphere of fear this policy change has generated is leading some families to reconsider whether to send their children to school. The fear hinges on the possibility of deportation-related incidents. Notably, major school districts in the Houston area operate their own police departments focused on student safety and managing criminal arrests. Importantly, these officers are not responsible for enforcing immigration laws. This separation of duties aims to preserve a safe environment conducive to learning without the added threat of immigration enforcement actions potentially disrupting the school day.

Legal and Educational Implications

The new DHS guidance does not alter the core laws regarding student enrollment in public schools, ensuring that institutions continue to admit students regardless of their immigration status. Moreover, school officials are neither required nor permitted to inquire about a student’s immigration status. This enduring practice reassures families that schools are dedicated to providing education to all children without discrimination based on legal residency. Responses from various school districts reveal how they are dealing with these policy changes and the concern among the immigrant community.

Houston Independent School District (HISD)

HISD Superintendent Mike Miles has maintained that the district’s procedures related to law enforcement activities on campus have not changed due to the new DHS guidance. The district’s legal services department provides student information to law enforcement only after a strict verification process to ensure it does not breach federal privacy protections. Additionally, HISD trains all staff and administrators to engage properly with law enforcement while safeguarding the rights of students. This measured approach aims to protect student information from unnecessary disclosure, maintaining trust between the school and the community it serves.

Alief Independent School District (ISD)

Alief ISD Superintendent Anthony Mays has actively communicated with the community to keep them informed and reassured. He emphasized ongoing consultations with legal counsel to navigate the implications of the new policy and encouraged parents to regularly update their children’s emergency contact details. This proactive engagement shows the district’s commitment to maintaining an open dialogue, reducing fears, and ensuring families feel supported. According to Kristyn Cathey, Alief ISD’s communications head, there has been no direct contact from DHS or ICE regarding this new immigration guideline.

Conroe Independent School District (ISD)

The Conroe ISD Police Department’s primary focus remains on maintaining campus safety and enforcing state and local laws. Executive Director of Communications, Sarah Blakelock, conveyed that while the department remains cooperative with federal, state, and local law enforcement for official investigations—including immigration-related inquiries—their main priority is the safety of students and staff. The department’s stance underlines the importance of a safe educational environment, free from the stress that potential immigration enforcement could bring.

Balancing Safety and Legal Compliance

Ensuring Student Safety

The central theme of navigating the balance between federal immigration enforcement policies and school responsibilities to provide a safe educational environment for all students is essential. This balancing act is further complicated by the Trump administration’s aggressive stance on immigration enforcement, which alarms immigrant communities. Schools must consistently assure students and families that educational environments will remain safe and stable despite external pressures. The responses from various schools demonstrate their commitment to this principle, as they adapt to policy changes while upholding student protection.

Legal Compliance and Protective Measures

Recent policy changes under the Trump administration concerning immigration enforcement in sensitive locations have alarmed many immigrant families in Houston. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) now permits Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents to make arrests in places like schools, hospitals, and churches, which were previously off-limits under a 2011 protocol. This change has led to widespread concern among families with undocumented members, fearing potential arrests at schools.

Before this policy shift, ICE agents could only conduct enforcement activities at sensitive locations if there was an urgent reason, such as a national security threat. The new directive allows ICE agents to arrest individuals believed to be in the country illegally if they have probable cause or a proper warrant. Probable cause could result from someone revealing their undocumented status or possessing documents that prove it. While no arrests have been reported at Houston schools so far, the uncertainty of future enforcement actions, especially as the administration ramps up efforts to deport undocumented immigrants, continues to incite fear among affected communities.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later