Is Ireland’s New Corporate Governance Code a Game-Changer for Companies?

October 24, 2024

On October 21, 2024, Euronext Dublin, the operator of the Irish stock exchange, introduced Ireland’s first-ever corporate governance code tailored for Irish companies. This landmark move is garnering significant attention and could mark the beginning of a new era for corporate governance in Ireland. Legal experts at McCann FitzGerald describe this development as a pivotal milestone for the Irish capital markets. Given the long-standing influence of the UK Corporate Governance Code as a global standard, the emergence of an Irish-specific code could bring about substantial changes in the corporate landscape. The new code aims to provide a greater level of flexibility for companies operating in Ireland, allowing them to adapt to the rapidly changing corporate, legal, and economic landscapes.

The Need for an Irish Corporate Governance Code

Ireland’s evolving economic and corporate landscape necessitated a localized approach to corporate governance. While the UK Code served as a benchmark, it was evident that a more flexible and contextually appropriate framework was required for Irish companies. The timing of the introduction of the new code aligns perfectly with the dynamic changes the Irish market is experiencing. Euronext Dublin’s effort to introduce this tailored code underscores Ireland’s desire to carve out a distinct corporate identity. It gives companies the maneuverability to better align their governance practices with local business needs and legal frameworks.

This significant development in Irish corporate laws is not just a reactionary measure but a proactive approach to fostering a robust, resilient corporate ecosystem. With the Irish market experiencing significant transformations, the new code provides a framework that can respond to the specific challenges and opportunities faced by Irish companies. It allows for autonomous governance that mirrors the unique cultural, economic, and legal landscape in Ireland, thus promoting a more effective and dynamic corporate governance framework.

Director Independence: A Closer Look

One of the primary differences between the Irish and UK codes lies in the stipulations regarding director independence. The Irish code employs a three-year lookback period for assessing director independence, in contrast to the UK’s five-year requirement. This nuanced change allows Irish companies greater flexibility when considering director appointments and assessing conflicts of interest. Such flexibility is instrumental in responding to corporate needs swiftly while maintaining robust governance standards. Directors who might have been disqualified under the UK code due to the longer lookback period now have the opportunity to serve, provided they meet the Irish criteria.

This change in director independence criteria reflects a balanced approach that ensures integrity and accountability without unnecessarily limiting the pool of eligible directors. It aligns with the broader goal of the Irish code to offer customized governance practices that resonate with the local business environment. By shortening the lookback period, the code enables companies to bring in directors who possess relevant recent experience and expertise, contributing to more innovative and responsive governance.

Shareholder Engagement and Reaction to Opposition

Another significant difference is how companies are advised to react when a substantial portion of shareholders vote against a board-recommended proposal. The Irish code sets this threshold at 25%, compared to the UK’s 20%. This subtle yet important adjustment signifies a more lenient approach, allowing boards to gauge shareholder sentiment without immediate drastic changes. By setting a higher threshold, the Irish code may encourage more constructive dialogues between boards and shareholders. It also reflects an understanding of the unique shareholder composition and engagement practices prevalent in Ireland.

This approach aims to foster a more collaborative atmosphere between boards and shareholders, promoting better understanding and mutual respect. It enables Irish companies to navigate shareholder disputes more diplomatically, ensuring that decisions reflect a broader consensus. The higher opposition threshold encourages boards to be more attuned to shareholder concerns while providing them with the space to implement strategic decisions without undue pressure.

Emphasis on Workforce Concerns

The Irish code places a strong emphasis on workforce concerns, mandating regular reviews of company policies that allow employees to voice concerns confidentially, with the option for anonymity. This move underscores a commitment to ethical governance and the well-being of employees, reflecting a broader trend towards corporate responsibility. Highlighting workforce concerns indicates a shift in governance focus towards ensuring that companies operate ethically and transparently. Employee welfare becomes a critical aspect of corporate governance, demonstrating an understanding that a satisfied and engaged workforce is a cornerstone of sustainable business success.

By prioritizing workforce concerns, the Irish code aims to create an inclusive corporate environment where employees feel valued and heard. This emphasis on ethical governance helps build a company culture of trust and integrity, which can enhance overall productivity and innovation. The code’s provisions for anonymous employee feedback ensure that concerns are raised without fear of retribution, fostering a safer and more open workplace atmosphere.

Diversity and Inclusion: A Core Principle

Diversity and inclusion are explicitly mandated in the Irish code, which requires companies to maintain policies on these issues. This focus on diverse governance frameworks aligns with global trends but is tailored to the Irish corporate context. By emphasizing diversity, the Irish code not only fosters inclusive workplace environments but also leverages diverse perspectives in decision-making processes. This requirement can drive innovation and resilience within Irish companies, positioning them favorably in the global marketplace.

Incorporating diversity and inclusion into governance practices is not merely a regulatory requirement but a strategic imperative for modern businesses. Diverse leadership teams are better equipped to understand and respond to a wide array of challenges, making companies more agile and competitive. The focus on these principles in the Irish code underscores a commitment to fair and equitable treatment and ensures that various viewpoints are considered in corporate strategy and operations.

Competence in the Audit Committee

The Irish code aligns with the phrasing in Ireland’s Companies Act 2014, requiring at least one member of the audit committee to possess “competence in accounting or auditing.” This contrasts with the UK’s requirement for “recent and relevant financial experience.” This subtle adjustment ensures that the audit committee is well-equipped to handle the financial intricacies of the business, aligning more closely with Irish legal requirements. It reaffirms the importance of having a committee that can effectively oversee financial reporting and risk management.

By specifying “competence in accounting or auditing,” the code seeks to ensure that audit committee members have a foundational understanding of financial principles necessary for robust oversight. This requirement supports the goal of maintaining high standards of financial governance and accountability. Having competent audit committee members ensures that financial statements are accurate and transparent, which is crucial for maintaining stakeholder trust and sustaining long-term business success.

Adapting to Rapidly Changing Economic Landscapes

One of the main differences between the Irish and UK corporate governance codes is in the criteria for director independence. The Irish code uses a three-year lookback period to assess director independence, while the UK’s period is five years. This slight adjustment provides Irish companies with more flexibility when appointing directors and evaluating conflicts of interest. Such flexibility helps companies respond to corporate needs more swiftly without sacrificing robust governance standards. Directors who might be disqualified under the UK’s longer lookback period can now serve, as long as they meet the Irish criteria.

This updated approach to director independence in Ireland strikes a balance between ensuring integrity and not unnecessarily narrowing the pool of eligible directors. It aligns with the Irish code’s goal of offering tailored governance practices suited to the local business environment. By shortening the lookback period, the code makes it easier for companies to appoint directors with relevant and recent experience, fostering more innovative and responsive governance. This change ultimately contributes to the agility and effectiveness of corporate boards in Ireland.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for subscribing.
We'll be sending you our best soon.
Something went wrong, please try again later